Lea Michele Was So Surprised When Cynthia Erivo Agreed to Sing on Her Christmas Album

PEOPLE Now airs live, Monday through Friday, from the Meredith offices in New York City. Catch PEOPLE Now every weekday at 12:00 p. m. ET/9 a.

m. PT on People. com or on the PeopleTV app on your favorite streaming device. Want even more?

Check out clips from previous episodes of PEOPLE Now.